Sunday, August 16, 2015

Anne Rice Is Furious and She Should Be (So Should You Be)

In recent months, author Anne Rice has been a vocal critic of what she considers to be an attempt to censor, entirely in the name of political correctness, what is being published.  Based on my own observations over the last year or two, I think what is happening is more of an attempt to keep certain books from having any success in the marketplace than it is an attempt to keep them from being produced.  But, of course, that really does amount to the same thing in the long run because, in a period like this one during which publishers seem willing to take on less and less risk all the time,  books about topics that don't sell well are not likely ever to hit the shelves.  

Those of us who regularly submit book reviews to sites know how easy it would be to create multiple identities on those sites...identities we could then use to submit a dozen or so very negative or very positive reviews of the same title.  And if you take a look at Amazon, you will see bunches of books that have lots of five-star or one-star reviews that are about three sentences long and really don't say a thing that makes much sense.  So there is no doubt that it happens.

In this Guardian interview, Rice has this to say:
“There are forces at work in the book world that want to control fiction writing in terms of who ‘has a right’ to write about what,” Rice said. “Some even advocate the out and out censorship of older works using words we now deem wholly unacceptable. Some are critical of novels involving rape. Some argue that white novelists have no right to write about people of colour; and Christians should not write novels involving Jews or topics involving Jews.”
“I think all this is dangerous. I think we have to stand up for the freedom of fiction writers to write what they want to write, no matter how offensive it might be to someone else. We must stand up for fiction as a place where transgressive behaviour and ideas can be explored … internet campaigns to destroy authors accused of inappropriate subject matter or attitudes are dangerous to us all.”

I have, at times, felt that Ms. Rice was a little oversensitive about some of the online reviews she criticized.  But in this case, I have no doubt that she is onto something that is a real danger - and not just a danger to authors and publishers.  It is a danger to our very right to free speech.

The interview specifically addresses what is happening to a novel by Kate Breslin called  For Such a Time that:
imagines a relationship between a Jewish woman in a concentration camp and an SS Kommandant, and her eventual conversion to Christianity. Critics called it “deeply offensive and insensitive”, as well as “antisemitic, violent, and dangerous”, with the widespread online debate prompting the appearance of dozens of one-star reviews of the novel on Amazon.

I am willing to bet that very, very few of the bad reviews are coming from people who have actually read the novel.  Maybe none.

I never heard of the book or its author before today, so I certainly have not read For Such a Time.  And I'm not reviewing it in this piece; I am simply making readers aware of the abuse this author and novel appear to be suffering at the hands of literary bigots who have no interest in debating a point or a topic.  These people prefer to shut down completely those who do not walk the same political line they walk.  "Goons" is the nicest thing I can think to call them.

So please consider joining with me and defying the Goon Squads.  I plan to mention this book many times in many places, and I just might read it so that I can give it an honest review.  I am so damned sick of political correctness that I could spit...

Entire Interview Here

Post# 2,534


  1. Ha! And in the art world, too. Museums will be ransacked if all works that offend pc are removed. I have a draft for a recent read and even included the "trigger warning" that the author makes because he knows elements will be considered offensive to certain groups. He felt it necessary to remind the reader that he writes fiction and that his book is a novel.

    1. It's a sad old world for sure. History is being rewritten right before our eyes. Who was it who said something like "those who control the past, control the future"? We all need to start fighting back and ridiculing those who use political correctness to silence us. I hope Rice gets a lot of attention for the cause by speaking up this way.

  2. There's no freedom of speech anymore. I enjoyed it, Sam. Thanks.

    1. We certainly have less every day, don't we? Thanks for stopping by and commenting. I appreciate it.

  3. I read that book. It's a retelling of the Biblical story of Esther. I didn't like it but it was far from offensive in any way. It's set in a WWII concentration camp - pretty difficult to not write about Jewish people in that context.

  4. The world is filled with people looking for reasons to be offended, Annie. Until we start telling them to grow up...and shut up...they will rule the world.