I first read Elmer Kelton’s Stand Proud sometime back in the eighties, and that was plenty long enough ago for this re-read to feel like I was reading it for the very first time. I remembered almost no details concerning the book’s plot, and had only a general memory of how much I enjoyed the story the first time around. It turns out that Stand Proud explores a theme that Larry McMurtry and quite a few other writers of westerns have explored in their own fiction over the years: what happens to violent men who outlive their usefulness to society once times have changed for the better.
Frank Claymore is one of those men.
During the Civil War, Frank had been one of the young militia men who stayed home to protect Texas settlers from the deadly raids of the Comanche Indians who were still not willing to cede Texas to the newcomers. The situation was so desperate that the Confederacy had to stop conscripting men from that part of the state so that the small farms and ranches could survive the war years. Twenty-two-year-old Frank was one of those small ranchers himself, but all able-bodied men were required to put time in with the militia - and he put in more than most.
Frank came out of the war years with three things: a wound that would plague him the rest of his life, the location of a remote grassland valley that he would claim for himself, and a mortal enemy and competitor for everything he held dearest.
And now, over 40 years later, Frank sits in a courtroom to be judged by a jury composed of small ranch owners who resent him and all he has claimed for himself. He is accused of murder, but is still determined to play by his own rules, damn the consequences. And it’s not looking good for him.
Each chapter of Stand Proud opens on a day of Frank’s trial, followed by a longer section from Frank’s past. This allows the reader to compare the young Frank Claymore to the elderly version, and to learn the truth, in detail, about what is being testified to in the courtroom. This construction works remarkably well to explain what kind of man Frank is and why someone as respected as he once was could find himself in a mess like this one so near the end of his life.
Stand Proud is nothing like the stereotypical pulp fiction western readers unfamiliar with the genre too often think of when they think “western” novel. This is a character-driven story in which relationships and longtime grudges drive all the action, a story where disagreements are more likely to be settled by fists rather than by guns. Kelton’s later novels, such as The Time It Never Rained, The Day the Cowboy’s Quit, and The Good Old Boys brought ever more realism to his stories about the cowboying life and its relationship to an ever-changing Texas landscape. The Western Writers of America once went so far as to proclaim Kelton “the greatest Western writer of all time.” I might not go quite that far in my praise of the man, but I will tell you that his fiction has entertained me for a long, long time. And that I appreciate him.
I read my first Elmer Kelton book, The Time It Never Rained, because of my naturalist group book club. This book sounds like a good book for all of us older folks. I went to a museum filled with kids on field trips, and I felt like I was in another world from the world I spent many years working as a teacher and a librarian.
ReplyDeleteDeb, this kind of book always reminds me just how recent the past is to the present day. I vaguely remember the stories my own grandmother told me about the Civil War that she heard from her grandfather. That kind of link just seems incredible these days. Texas, as it was in this book, was a whole different world - but the people were people just like they are today. That’s what this book is really all about.
ReplyDeleteI always used to wonder as a young teen, addicted to cowboy TV series, exactly how realistic they were. I suppose the answer is, not very, but perhaps with elements of truth woven in. This sounds like a powerful novel and I enjoyed reading about it in your review, Sam.
ReplyDeleteThose old shows were centered more on gunfights than anything else, and in the real world that kind of gunfighting was pretty rare. Some of Kelton’s earlier books are more that way, but his later ones show a lot of the dreariness and bleakness of what cowboying really was like. I really like his later books a lot because of that.
DeleteThis does sound like a good book. The structure as you described it is the kind I like. I will look for this book or others by him (at the book sale or later if I am not lucky there.)
ReplyDeleteI hope you find one of his good ones, Tracy. Good luck.
DeleteI love when you can revisit a favorite author and his books years after you first read them and not be disappointed. I need to read some of his novels; I do love a good Western.
ReplyDeleteThat’s always a relief for me when it happens. I think you’ll like him because he’s not one of the pulp style writers, he aimed his later books squarely at adults.
Delete