Forbidden Notebook very much reflects the state of Italian culture, especially the relationship between husbands and wives, during the period during which it was was first published. Even so, it still surprises me that the novel was written in 1952, not written in retrospect some decades later. Thankfully, Astra House republished a Forbidden Notebook translation by Ann Goldstein in 2023, or I would most certainly have never heard of it.
As the novel opens, Valeria is married and has a husband, a son in university, and a teen daughter about to finish high school. She's pretty much resigned herself to her life, even though she's not completely happy with being a full-time caretaker to three other adults. But all it will take is one innocent decision to change the lives of her entire family forever.
It all begins when Valeria goes to a tobacconist to buy cigarettes for her husband one Sunday afternoon. According to Italian law, legally the shop can only sell tobacco products on Sundays, nothing else, but Valeria manages to coerce the shop owner into selling her the blank journal that catches her eye. Valeria has been bothered that she has no private space of her own to claim: her husband has his study, and her children each have a bedroom of their own. She, however, has no place to be alone, and when she gets back home that Sunday afternoon, Valeria realizes that she doesn't even have a place to hide the journal from the prying eyes of her family- much less the actual opportunity to sit and write down her own secrets and personal feelings about what goes on around her. She's never before had the time to think much about herself in relationship to her husband and children, and how she really feels about the way each of them takes for granted that she will always be there to do whatever they need her to do for them.
But Valeria figures it out. She starts staying up long after everyone else has gone to sleep with the excuse that she needs to finish up one more household task or another. Nervous as it all makes her, she has carved out a little private time for herself, and she makes the most of it. Gradually, Valeria begins to realize that the very act of composing her thoughts before putting them to paper has made her see her world and her family in a way she never has before. And she begins to realize that she wants more from life - and more importantly that she deserves more.
The author very cleverly uses Valeria's written words exclusively to tell of her transformation, so the reader is able to watch it all happen exactly as she experiences it. This works remarkably well to pace the novel in a way that allows the reader's eyes to be opened to a more realistic view of what Italian women of the fifties were experiencing layer by layer, just as Valeria was figuring it all out for herself layer by layer.
Forbidden Notebook is a brilliant novel with a lot to say - and thanks to Astra House, you don't have to miss it.
Alba De Céspedes jacket photo |
This definitely sounds like my kind of book! I've added it to my list... thanks for the review.
ReplyDeleteThis woman was really good, and it's a shame that she slipped through the cracks the way she did. It's surprising that she's been republished in this country so many years later (at least to me), but I'm really happy that it happened.
DeleteI was ready to dismiss this one as not for me, but the more I read your review of it the more I began to think that this is a book I would probably really like. Thanks for adding yet another book to my TBR list. ;D
ReplyDeleteThe TBR mountain, you mean. It's a good thing mine is not a physical stack of books because it would probably be on the verge of collapsing under its own weight.
DeleteVery fine e review Sam and I am putting it on my goodreads want to read shelf. I love diaries either real or fiction. One thing about real diaries is that it can be problematic to be honest because someone could read what you have to say about them and get hurt. Fortunately the fictional Valeria doesn't have that worry.
ReplyDeleteShe doesn't really, but that was one of Valeria's concerns. What if she suddenly died in an accident and the diary was found by a family member? Big concern for her. Her struggle to find a safe hiding place for the notebook was a key clue to her personality early on in the novel. Makes me much more sympathetic of those authors who have instructed their agents to destroy their personal papers and letters upon their deaths. I used to find that a selfish thing to do to their reading public; now I think I was the selfish one to feel that way.
DeleteI came back to reread this review after reading Kathy's at Reading Matters. I thought I had commented on it before. Anyway, it does sound like an interesting read and I usually like diaries so I shall have to be on the lookout for a copy. Amazing that it got rescued and reissued recently
ReplyDeleteI agree, Tracy. When something like this is "rediscovered" and turns out to be so good, it always makes me wonder what other treasures are lost to the reading world. It also makes me wonder why I spend so much time chasing the latest hit books when I might be better off looking for some mid-twentieth century stuff to explore.
Delete