Remarkably Bright Creatures was one of the hottest books of 2022 and, at least in my recollection, of 2023. I got on my library wait list a little late and finally threw in the towel when I realized that it would be most of a year before I would get hold of it that way. It wasn't until this year that I thought about the novel again and decided to get back on the list - and I still started at number 65. But I had also signed up for the large print edition book and started the wait for that one in the mid-twenties. As it turns out, the wait for that edition was only three weeks, and I spent a lot of time last week finally reading Remarkably Bright Creatures. With just a few pages to go, I'm still not sure what to think of it - and that's probably not a good thing.
I did finish up both Alice McDermott's Absolution and the Mark Twain classic The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn as well, and made good starts on James Lee Burke's Clete and Alan Murrin's The Coast Road. Too, I've started re-reading Anne Tyler's Dinner at the Homesick Restaurant, the novel that turned me into a lifetime fan of Tyler's work the first time that I read it back in the eighties - and I'm down to the last short story in Joan Leegant's Displaced Persons. This was one of those weeks that I found it particularly hard to focus, so I found myself moving from book to book quicker than I normally do, with shorter bursts of reading that I don't find nearly as satisfying as reading at least fifty or so pages from one book before moving on to the next. I do hope that changes this week.
Clete is a little bit different in that it is being correctly marketed as book number 24 in James Lee Burke's Dave Robicheaux series despite Dave being very much a secondary character in the novel - at least through the first third of the book. This time around the narrator is Clete Purcell, a private investigator who has been Dave's closest friend since their days in Vietnam. Once again, Dave and Clete are dealing with some truly evil people in small town Louisiana, but it's been eye-opening to see Dave through the eyes of a man who knows him better than anyone else in the world could ever know him. (I've read the first 23 books in the series so it's interesting to learn that Clete sees him a bit differently than I see him.)I'm about thirty percent of the way through The Coast Road and I still haven't settled into it comfortably. The characters, all of whom are women with marital problems of one degree or another, have not separated themselves in my mind yet, and that makes it hard to keep up with the intricacies of their day-to-day experiences together. It's still hard to know which of them can be relied on to tell the truth and which of them are lying to themselves. I do expect this one to suck me in soon - well at least I hope that's about to happen.I first read Dinner at the Homesick Restaurant in 1983 or so, and it turned out to be one of those books that influenced my reading for decades to come. It made me a lifetime fan of Anne Tyler's work, and I've pretty much read everything she's ever written now. But guess what? I don't remember a whole lot about the plot anymore, only how immersed I ended up being in the world Tyler created and how fascinating I found the characters to be. This is one of those risky re-reads that I hope doesn't end up lessening my fondness for a book that's been on my shelves for a long, long time.Oh, and I also gave up on Susan Orlean's On Animals because the pieces I read from the essay collection didn't seem to work together as a whole. Maybe if I had read them as standalone magazine articles they would have struck me differently.
The little stack of books still waiting for their turn includes this bunch:
That's my Monday morning start to the week. I do have a couple of short road trips scheduled for later this week: a baseball game against Arkansas over in College Station and a lunch date with a few of my old high school friends down toward Beaumont, but it looks like we're in for another round of hard rains that are likely to wash out both trips. Whether that ends up translating into more reading time or more time frittered away remains to be seen.
I hope you are all doing well, and I hope to visit a bunch of blogs this week that I missed out on last week...have fun.
Even if you don't know what to think about Remarkably Bright Creatures, you have to at least like Marcellus, right? Octopuses are great escape artists in real life; I had fun reading about his nighttime forays through the aquarium. He was a fun character imo.
ReplyDeleteWithout Marcellus I would probably not have finished this one at all. The poor guy was barely there for the first sixty pages or so...but my curiosity about him kept me reading anyway. But wow...an octopus who taught himself to read English? I love the concept but that kind of changed the genre of the book for me. LOL
DeleteAt the time of reading I liked RBC a lot. I think it was last year. Since then my keeness has dimmed a bit and I remember how annoying the young man was in it and there wasn't enough of Marcellus. Funny how time can curb your enthusiasm quite substantially!
ReplyDeleteThat guy, Cath, might have worked better for me if he had be twenty years old; but as a 30-year-old, I found him really irritating and hard to put up with. I'll have more to say about this book in a few days, I'm sure, but I came to the conclusion that this one rode a wave of publicity it really didn't much deserve.
DeleteThe audio version elevated Remarkably Bright Creatures from good book to a great book for me. The voice of Marcellus was perfect! The young man was so annoying , but the audio seemed to make that fade into the background. I've read most of Anne Tyler, too, but don't remember the plots of those early titles. Will be curious to hear about your rereading experience.
ReplyDeleteI've had exactly the same thing happen, JoAnn. It amazes me just how much difference to a novel the right reader/narrator can make. There are a few that I would listen to them reading just about anything to me.
DeleteRBC was brand new when I was studying in London in 2022 and I found the British cover so appealing that I kept picking it up, then discarding it when I read the description. My parents brought me back from Scandinavia that identical wooden horse when I was 5 and I still have it! But the book really does not sound very appealing. See https://www.amazon.com/Remarkably-Bright-Creatures/dp/1526649667
ReplyDeleteI have not read much Anne Tyler. In fact, I can't remember if I read Homesick Restaurant or Accidental Tourist but I wouldn't mind trying another. I sometimes confuse her books and Sue Miller's - both are sort of book-groupy but I guess I have read more of the latter.
I do think the basic premise of the book is clever, but for me it crossed the line when Marcellus the octopus revealed that he could read and even recognize distantly related human beings, etc. At that point, it started to feel like a romance novel disguised as a fairy tale...or a fable.
DeleteTyler does remind me a little of Sue Miller's work, or someone like Gail Godwin (although Godwin's books are much longer). With Tyler, it's the characters that always grab and hold me; her plots are usually rather simple ones, really, but those characters, strange as they can be, really stick in my mind.
Oh, dear- I've had Remarkably Bright Creatures on my TBR for a while, but this comment reveals to me I'll probably have some issues with it and not enjoy as much as I'd hoped. I think the exact same detail would be what ruins it for me.
ReplyDeleteIt's probably my fault, but I expected a more "serious" novel - didn't do my research. That made the disappointment greater than it would have otherwise been, I suspect. Basically, it's a romance novel that could be turned into a good movie in the right hands.
DeleteOh I hope you don't have flooding in your area. I've heard the power is out to a lot of people in Texas. I'd like The Coast Road novel as I can imagine how bad it was for women in particular before divorce was legalized in Ireland. I did not care for the Bright Creatures novel ... except for the octopus ... as the story turned out more weak than expected and the boy in story acted so young for his age. Hmm. See what you think. I agree the Homesick Restaurant was so long ago that I don't remember it anymore and would need a reread ... I hope it still manages to be good.
ReplyDeleteWe really got lucky this time around. We missed the bulk of the high winds and heavy rains because we were in some kind of pocket between hard hit areas. It was a disaster to the north of us, and an even greater disaster to the south of us. Over a million people were without power for hours, and it will be days more for some. Four dead, I think from falling trees. My grandson had to spend the night in his office building, but at his age it was just all one big adventure.
DeleteI just finished The Coast Road this morning, and it's perking away in my mind. My general impression of it is positive because I suspect it really captured the times very well for those women. Remarkably Bright Creatures was a big disappointment to me. It's really a romance novel disguised as something more.
Every now and then I think of Remarkably Bright Creatures because so many reviews have been positive, and I will try it out when I find an inexpensive copy. I am not eager enough to add it to my stacks right now.
ReplyDeleteI am coming up with a list of summer reading and I will be reading a book by Anne Tyler for sure. I got an eBook copy of McDermott's Absolution yesterday and hope I don't let it slip into the abyss of kindle books unread.
I wouldn't rush it, Tracy, and certainly wouldn't overpay for a copy. In the long run, it's just fluff. At least for me, that is.
DeleteI'll look forward to seeing and hearing about whatever Anne Tyler novel you choose. I wonder how many more we will get from Ms. Tyler, if any. Keeping my fingers crossed that she's not done yet.
I know exactly what you mean about kindle books slipping through the crack. That's my only complaint anymore about e-book readers; there's just no easy way to browse the shelves effectively at all. I usually get tired of scrolling pages way before I've gone through most of what I have. Sometimes sorting them differently helps, but that's kind of redundant, too, so it's all frustrating.